Meeting the standard for tourism, hospitality and events is a two-part process which involves external peer-review of assessment and calibration of academic standards. Meeting the Standard builds on the work of:
- The Setting the Standard: Establishing Threshold Learning Outcomes (TLOs) for Tourism, Hospitality and Events Higher Education in Australia website contains material, information and resources gathered as part of the academic standards project funded by the Office for Learning and Teaching (OLT) in 2013.
- The Tourism, Hospitality and Events Learning and Teaching Academic Standards Higher Education, the outcome of the above project, is a set of nationally agreed upon and clearly articulated TLOs for tourism, hospitality and events higher education coursework programs at Australian Qualification Framework bachelor (level 7) and coursework masters (level 9).
- External Referencing of Standards (ERoS)
- Achievement matters: external peer review of accounting learning standards
- Assessment Design Principles
- THE Comprehensive Rubric
- Detailed assessment examples of how educators can document students’ mastery of the agreed upon TLOs through various curriculum, pedagogy and assessment practices.
A workshop on Implementation of the standards at my institution: Understanding the enablers and barriers for adoption will be held on Friday 24 February | 1:00-3:00pm (AEDT) via Zoom. Please contact the CAUTHE Secretariat if you would like to be involved.
Mid-Year JHTM Special Edition workshop – 22 July 2022
The 2022 Mid-Year TH&E Standards Workshop will be held online from 14:00-16:30 pm on Friday 22 July 2022 (AEST). The purpose of the workshop is to develop a JHTM Special Issue plan. The goals and expectations will be outlined by the Editor-in-Chief and Special Issue editors. Members will self-allocate into topic area groups, craft ideas, gain feedback, and develop a paper plan. A timeline for completion will be developed.
Please contact the CAUTHE Secretariat if you would like further information about and/or registration details for this workshop.
Best practice in academic staffing: Auditing, mapping, and developing staff knowledge, skills, qualifications – 3 February 2022
This workshop continued the work of 2020-2021 Course and Assessment Design workshop series, in which the threshold learning outcomes journey, from course design to benchmarking was tracked. This workshop focussed on accreditation, including academic staffing: qualifications, professional experience, scholarly activity, and the related maintaining of these; a common demonstration challenge. The workshop was held in the week prior to the CAUTHE 2022 Hybrid conference. There was no charge for registration for CAUTHE members or one Chapter representative from each institution if attending the workshop only.
2021 Assessment Planning and Benchmarking workshops
Assessment Planning workshop – 25 June 2021
The aims of this online workshop were to:
- outline a systematic planning process for the design and development of an assessment program for students’ scaffolded demonstration of the tourism, hospitality and events threshold learning outcomes (TLOs).
- utilise the constructive alignment approach to centralise the TLO demonstration within the assessment program.
Importantly, it was highlighted that the approach can and should be nested within the wider outcome and assessment requirements of the degree program. A participant wrote following the workshop: I have just watched the Zoom recording and the material presented on the complexities of assessment design was amazing, great job guys! Glen is surely THE expert on constructive alignment and assessment/rubric design!!
Benchmarking workshop – 16 July 2021
This successful online workshop focussed on quality metrics and quality improvement. Benchmarking is a quality improvement process using comparisons between current performance and past performance or other institutions’ performance. Importantly, benchmarking is a core element to TEQSA accreditation processes. The value of cross-institutional benchmarking was also discussed. Feedback from the workshop included: Thank you so much team COPs [College of Peers]!! Always a fantastic and eye opening (brain bending) experience.
2019-2020 Assessment Design workshops
Assessment Design Workshop 5 – 4 February 2021
A TH&E Standards workshop was held online in the week prior to the annual CAUTHE 2021 Online Conference. The workshop continued the work of 2020 Mid-year workshop series, at which participants developed a TH&E Comprehensive rubric which addresses the tourism, hospitality and events Standards, from first-year N-/Low-Fail to graduate Masters HD. The workshop aimed to generate guidelines for specific assessment design as aligned with rubric, domains, and threshold learning outcomes. Download Agenda.
Assessment Design Workshop 4 – June/July 2020
The CAUTHE College of Peers met online over four meetings to complete this work. The outcome of the meetings was the development of a comprehensive rubric to measure students’ achievement of the tourism, hospitality, and events threshold learning outcomes. The rubric includes measures of student demonstration across the five domains (Service and Experience Design, Interdisciplinary Inquiry, Collaboration, Problem Solving, and Professional Responsibility), from first year bachelor’s through to final year master’s level. Download Program of Activities.
Assessment Design Workshop 3 – 10 February 2020
The all-day workshop was held immediately prior to the CAUTHE 2020 conference in Auckland, New Zealand. It was attended by 22 participants from 16 institutions and organisations. Participants presented exemplars in the fields of tourism, hospitality and events, which had been developed over previous workshops. The workshop then focussed on course mapping and scaffolding across programs, and rubric design.
The Executive committee expressed its sincere thanks to Assoc Prof Pierre Benckendorff and acknowledges Pierre’s enduring contribution to the development of the Standards, calibration and assessment design activities since funding was first obtained in 2013. Download Agenda.
Assessment Design Workshop 2 – 15 July 2019
The five domain participant volunteers from each of the three FIELDs, plus additional participants in attendance, worked together to develop principles around best practice assessments for FIELDS, and an ideal assessment for a FIELD. For more 2019 Mid-year meeting, HDR conference and workshops.
Assessment Design Workshop 1 – 11 February 2019
Peers developed and presented a ‘fit for purpose’, exemplary assessment to cover each of the five DOMAINS (Service and Experience Design, Interdisciplinary Inquiry, Collaboration, Problem Solving and Professional Responsibility) in each of the three FIELDS of study (tourism, hospitality or events) – a total of 15 assessment items. At the workshop each triad presented their work to the larger group which then developed principles around best practice assessments for DOMAINS. Download Agenda.
2017-2018 Calibration of Academic Standards
Calibration of Academic Standards (CAS) is a multistage intervention in which external peer reviewers examine an assessment task and samples of student work against one or more of the threshold learning standard domains before, during and after a calibration workshop. CAUTHE hosted CAS workshops during 2017-2018. The workshops aimed to:
- Reach a shared understanding of what it means to meet the minimum standard in a chosen domain
- Generate a shared understanding about assessments and outcome standards in comparable units being taught in different institutions
The body of material collected from calibration workshops informed the review of the 2015 TH&E Learning and Teaching Academic Standards. For more see:
2016-2017 Peer review of assessment
Peers who were acknowledged as discipline experts, reviewed and reported on the assessment methods and grading of students’ achievement of learning outcomes with reference to the tourism, hospitality and events (TH&E) Learning and Teaching Academic Standards. This collaborative process provided evidence that assessments and grading standards were appropriate and broadly comparable with those assessment practices occurring in other similar programs elsewhere. Participants from interested Chapter member institutions were invited to participate in this process. Download:
Building a college of peers workshop – 5 August 2016
- Minutes: TH&E Building a College of Peers workshop
- Background information: TH&E Building a College of Peers
- ERoS External Referencing of Standards report template (6 June 2016)
- ERoS Accompanying guide and information (6 June 2016)
- Lawson, R Assuring learning: Course mapping and data collection for assurance of learning
- Freeman, M External peer review models for coursework degrees (5 September 2014)
- Bedford, Simon; Czech, Peter; Sefcik, Lesley; Smith, Judith; and Yorke, John, (2016), External Referencing of Standards (ERoS) – An example of a collaborative end-to-end peer review process for external referencing, Curtin University, Queensland University of Technology, University of Wollongong and RMIT University, 2016, 61p https://ro.uow.edu.au/uowbooks/13
The project team is comprised of invited participants from CAUTHE Chapter member institutions, many of whom were involved with the original Setting the Standard project. For more information or if you are interested in participating in Meeting the Standard for tourism, hospitality and events contact the CAUTHE Secretariat.
The Hotel School, Southern Cross University
School of Tourism & Hospitality Management
Southern Cross University
Department of Management